Skip to main content

Book Review: The Long Dark Road to Wizardry by Richard K. Lyon

I'll start by saying that this is not a traditionally-published novel, which is why you've never heard of it. It was serialized in the online webzine Bewildering Stories. Since that very same webzine just rejected one of my own stories, I thought I'd do a review of something they published. Yes, I am vengeful and petty. So let me get to the point: The Long Dark Road to Wizardry is a cliche fantasy novel with very little character development and a plot that was interesting but ultimately unsatisfying. Harsh, I know. This novel takes place in some medieval fantasy land where people say 'twas all the time. I don't mind this so much; I like a good classic medieval fantasy. The plot is more episodic than an actual novel plot should be, with the characters having dramatic adventures seemingly one after the other. There is an overall plot, but , think it could have been fleshed out more. Again, I don't really mind this. What bothered me was the lack of character development. We start off with Druin, who finds out he inherited some magic powers from his grandfather and now he needs to explore his talents in order to avenge the slaughter of his friends and family. Interesting premise, but I feel like it doesn't get developed beyond that. After a few adventures with Druin, we suddenly switch the point of view to his cousin Breen, who is predictably good at everything, has black-and-white morals, and is basically less interesting to read about. Druin seems to go from traumatized young man to hardcore wizard overnight, and we don't get to see any of his growth. It's disappointing. Also, there is a romance thrown in at the very end between Breen and some flat, helpless princess character, which is extremely sudden, unrealistic, and not well-written. This novel was written some time in the '70s, I think, so I can forgive some of the cliches, and I understand that this was probably meant to be a simple adventure novel. It was exciting enough that I read the whole thing, so there's that. But the plot and especially the characters needed to be developed more to make the story feel even remotely realistic, relatable, and satisfying. So there: I have taken my revenge on Bewildering Stories (insert evil laugh) Just kidding, I would have written this review even if my story had gotten published in this magazine. You can read the full novel here if you're interested.. Now to try and get my work published elsewhere.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Storm Front by Jim Butcher Commentary and Spoilers

After many months I am finally back to blogging! I read the entire Dresden Files series by Jim Butcher (fifteen books so far) several years ago. Now I am listening to the audio book versions of every book. They are read by the amazing James Marsters. Going through the story a second time has refreshed my memory and given me a lot of new perspectives and opinions, and I will write them down here because I have no life. Just kindding, I do have a life, at least somewhat, but that doesn't stop me from being a supernerd about fantasy novels. So here are my thoughts on Storm Front, book 1 of the Dresden Files. THERE MAY BE SPOILERS! This is the first book in the series that started a whole new genre of urban fantasy mystery novels. And it's good. I've heard that a lot of people don't think the series gets good until after the first couple of books, but I don't think that's fair. Butcher couldn't pack the entire world of Harry Dresden into the first novel; it wou...

Book Review: The Magicians by Lev Grossman

This one is an urban fantasy; everyone compares it to Harry Potter and Narnia. That's because it uses most of the same plot devices: an unhappy young man (Quentin Coldwater) gets into a school for magic, and he is fascinated with this Narnia-like fantasy world called Fillory. People complain about how Grossman kind of lazily combined the plots of Harry Potter and Narnia instead of coming up with his own original storyline. But I don't mind familiar plot devices as long as the author does something interesting with them, and I guess I can say that Grossman achieves this. It's certainly interesting enough. This doesn't mean that the plot doesn't have its flaws. It takes strange, unexpected turns, so that it's impossible to even make a guess at where the story is going. This can be exciting, or frustrating, depending on the reader. I think I would have appreciated a little more foreshadowing, so that things had more of a sense of coming together in the end. Like, ...

Book Review: A Quest Of Heroes by Morgan Rice

This is the first book in Morgan Rice's The Sorcerer's Ring series, about a boy named Thor who is struggling to be a knight, defeat evil, be with the princess, all those things that boys do in cliche fantasy novels. Rice is a self-published author who has become very well-known. It's not because of the strength of her writing, though. This boek is truly awful. It's so bad, in just about every way. I agree with every sentiment expressed in this wonderfully-written review but let me add a few of my own. First of all, the prose is really terrible. There are grammar mistakes, awkward phrasing, continuity errors in the plot ... but okay, so we don't all have a talent for poetic language. Honestly, though, did this author even do ANY revising? At least try! The plot is, of course, a collection of every overused fantasy cliché ever. But, again, that alone is not enough to make the book the affront to fantasy that it is. The clichés were so poorly executed that I felt p...